Skip to product information
Mystery Earrings from our collection are showcased beside a cream vase, with "Mystery Earrings" featured at the center.
  • Mystery Earrings from our collection are showcased beside a cream vase, with "Mystery Earrings" featured at the center.
  • Mystery Earrings from our collection, featuring gold and opal designs in various styles, are displayed on a light surface beside a white vase.
  • A wavy-edged ceramic dish holds the elegant Mystery Earrings collection, featuring assorted gold hoops and studs, adding charm to a beige surface.
  • Discover Mystery Earrings—a captivating collection of gold and pearl earrings and studs elegantly displayed on a soft beige surface, perfect for fans who love the thrill of surprise jewelry.
Mystery Earrings
Ready to Ship

Mystery Earrings

35 reviews

$9.50 $19.00

In stock and ships next day!

Last Chance: Hurry and save

Embark on a style adventure with our Mystery Earrings! Every pair is a delightful surprise waiting to be unveiled, offering an exciting addition to your earring collection.

Happiness Guarantee

Easy 14-Day Returns

Free U.S Shipping

Product details
  • Material: 925 Sterling Silver | Resin | 18K Gold Over Brass | White Gold Over Brass
  • Surprise Finish: You'll receive either 18K Gold or Sterling Silver
  • Final Sale

SKU: RR-ER569
Shipping & Care
  • Free Shipping on U.S Orders
  • Eco-friendly, ready to gift packaging
  • Carefully hand crafted and made to last ♡
  • 90-day Warranty

CM GIVES BACK

Every purchase helps protect our planet. We proudly donate 1% of our proceeds to organizations working to preserve and restore the environment through 1% for the Planet. Learn more about our Sustainability efforts.

Pairs well with
All deliveries are carbon neutral

You may also like
5.0
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars
Based on 35 reviews
35 reviews
  • Allison W.
    Verified Buyer
    11/5/25
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Definitely doing this again

    I decided to add these onto my order because why not! And they picked these out for me that I neverrr would have picked for myself and now I can't stop wearing them lol

    Was this helpful?
  • Jaimie B.
    Verified Buyer
    10/18/25
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    So cute!

    I got the CUTEST purple gemstone earrings for my mystery earrings. Such a cute pair for a great value!

    Was this helpful?
  • Anna F.
    Verified Buyer
    10/8/25
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Loved what I was sent

    The earrings were a good match with the other jewelry I ordered

    Was this helpful?
  • Christa P.
    Verified Buyer
    7/31/25
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Awesome

    Loved these but they can be hard to put on

    Was this helpful?
  • Aly L.
    Verified Buyer
    6/15/25
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Fun surprise

    This was my first time getting any mystery pack, and it was such a fun surprise getting earrings hand picked for me! I love what I received and it feels extra special.

    Was this helpful?
Show More