Mystery Earrings from our collection are showcased beside a cream vase, with "Mystery Earrings" featured at the center.

Mystery Earrings

$24.00
$24.00 $35.00
Skip to product information
Mystery Earrings from our collection are showcased beside a cream vase, with "Mystery Earrings" featured at the center.
  • Mystery Earrings from our collection are showcased beside a cream vase, with "Mystery Earrings" featured at the center.
  • Mystery Earrings from our collection, featuring gold and opal designs in various styles, are displayed on a light surface beside a white vase.
  • A wavy-edged ceramic dish holds the elegant Mystery Earrings collection, featuring assorted gold hoops and studs, adding charm to a beige surface.
  • Discover Mystery Earrings—a captivating collection of gold and pearl earrings and studs elegantly displayed on a soft beige surface, perfect for fans who love the thrill of surprise jewelry.
Mystery Earrings
Ready to Ship

Mystery Earrings

38 reviews

$24.00
$24.00 $35.00
FRIENDS & FAMILY SALE 🤍
BOGO 50% Off Sitewide ✨ No code needed. Exclusions apply

In stock and ships next day!

Last Chance: Hurry and save

Embark on a style adventure with our Mystery Earrings! Every pair is a delightful surprise waiting to be unveiled, offering an exciting addition to your earring collection.

Happiness Guarantee

Final Sale

Free U.S Shipping

Product details
  • Material: 925 Sterling Silver ∙ Resin ∙ 18K Gold Over Brass ∙ Rhodium Over Brass
  • Surprise Color: You'll receive either 18K Gold or Sterling Silver
  • Final Sale

SKU: RR-ER569
Shipping & Care
  • Free Shipping on U.S Orders
  • Eco-friendly, ready to gift packaging
  • Carefully crafted and made to last ♡
  • 90-day Warranty

CM GIVES BACK

Every purchase helps protect our planet. We proudly donate 1% of our proceeds to organizations working to preserve and restore the environment through 1% for the Planet. Learn more about our Sustainability efforts.

Pairs well with

You may also like
5.0
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars
Based on 38 reviews
Slide 1 selected
38 reviews
  • Ellie H.
    Verified Buyer
    5/19/26
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Mystery Earrings

    Super fun! Received silver and opal huggies that made a great gift for a friend's birthday.

    Was this helpful?
  • Rachel P.
    Verified Buyer
    2/11/26
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Mystery earrings were a hit

    I bought a bunch of thing at the same time and threw in some mystery earrings for funsies! They were so cute and very much matched the vibes of the rest of my order!

    Was this helpful?
  • KEREN P.
    Verified Buyer
    1/6/26
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    The fun in a mystery

    Now and then, I love a good mystery box, and having the items be jewelry is the cherry on top. I got a pair of mismatched heart/teddy-bear earrings and love wearing them with girly scrubs. Love my mystery pair.

    Was this helpful?
  • Allison W.
    Verified Buyer
    11/5/25
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Definitely doing this again

    I decided to add these onto my order because why not! And they picked these out for me that I neverrr would have picked for myself and now I can't stop wearing them lol

    Was this helpful?
  • Jaimie B.
    Verified Buyer
    10/18/25
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    So cute!

    I got the CUTEST purple gemstone earrings for my mystery earrings. Such a cute pair for a great value!

    Was this helpful?
Show More