- Amy H.Verified Buyer7/7/26Rated 5 out of 5 starsMystery
Would purchase again
Was this helpful? - AlyssaVerified Buyer6/23/26Rated 5 out of 5 stars5 Stars
I’ve never opted in to buy a mystery box. I’ve always been nervous to pay something unseen. That said, I’ve been consistently impressed with all the pieces I’ve purchased from Caitlyn Minimalist and knew I’d love whatever came. I received 2 gold huggie earrings (very on brand with my previous orders). I’m so happy I decided to give the mystery box a try. Thanks again for another beautiful piece
Was this helpful? - Kristen P.Verified Buyer11/22/25Rated 5 out of 5 starsMy favorite subscription box
I have 25 ear piercings so this is an inexpensive way to get new pieces monthly for my multiple piercings. I absolutely adore this subscription and love all the items picked for me. I have the silver version and have had the subscription probably around 6 months at this point. Highly recommend if you like surprise monthly pieces to spice up your ear stack. :)
Was this helpful? - Claire T.Verified Buyer10/30/25Rated 5 out of 5 starsSubscription
Amazing quality and beautiful earrings!!
Was this helpful? - Kristin H.Verified Buyer10/18/25Rated 5 out of 5 starsBeautiful quality and fun surprise!
I have been blown away by the quality of the pieces for the monthly earring subscription box. Loving the variety of the pieces. I subscribed because a lot of my jewelry needed updating and I thought this would be a fun way to do it.
Was this helpful?
Mystery Earrings Box
18K Gold
$34.30
Sale price
$34.30
Regular price
$49.00
Skip to product information
🍒 MIX & MATCH SALE 🍒
BOGO 50% Off Sitewide. Exclusions apply
Gift-Worthy: Perfect for any occasion
Let us take away the stress of choosing the perfect earrings, we have you covered! With our Mystery Earrings Box, you will receive 3 pairs of randomly picked earrings (value of more than $90). If your jewelry collection is in need of a spruce up, you won't get better than this!
Happiness Guarantee
Final Sale
Free U.S Shipping
Product details
Shipping & Care
- Free Shipping on U.S Orders
- Eco-friendly, ready to gift packaging
- Carefully crafted and made to last ♡
- 180-day Warranty
CM GIVES BACK
Every purchase helps protect our planet. We proudly donate 1% of our proceeds to organizations working to preserve and restore the environment through 1% for the Planet. Learn more about our Sustainability efforts.You may also like