Skip to product information
The Birthstone Mystery Box features a gold necklace and earrings with red and green gemstones, elegantly displayed in pink square boxes on a light surface, offering a personalized surprise.
  • The Birthstone Mystery Box features a gold necklace and earrings with red and green gemstones, elegantly displayed in pink square boxes on a light surface, offering a personalized surprise.
  • Hands hold a Birthstone Mystery Box with a gold necklace and earrings featuring green gemstones against a peach background—a personalized gift perfect for any occasion.
  • Birthstone Mystery Box
  • A woman with long brown hair smiles in warm light, touching her chest as she wears gold earrings and a necklace—her look suggests the Birthstone Mystery Box, a personalized surprise set with matching necklace and earrings.
  • The Birthstone Mystery Box features gold jewelry with opal insets, including a necklace, earrings, and a ring, beautifully packaged for a personalized surprise.
  • The Birthstone Mystery Box features gold jewelry with green gemstones in a pink box, including a necklace, earrings, rings, and a teardrop pendant—ideal for gifting or a personalized surprise.
  • Birthstone Mystery Box featuring a gold and green gemstone necklace and earrings set, elegantly displayed in a pink frame atop white textured stones.
  • Gold and green gemstone necklace and earring set in a pink display case with a Caitlyn Minimalist box—perfect as a Birthstone Mystery Box or for a personalized surprise gift.
  • Discover each month's gemstone, including garnet, amethyst, emerald, and ruby. Perfect for a personalized surprise or pair with our Birthstone Mystery Box featuring a necklace and earrings.
Birthstone Mystery Box
Ready to Ship

Birthstone Mystery Box

5 reviews

$30.50 $61.00
FINISH
BIRTHSTONEGarnet / January

In stock and ships next day!

Last Chance: Hurry and save

Indulge in the magic of a personalized surprise that’s just for you! Good things comes in threes with our Birthstone Mystery Box - we will randomly handpick an assortment of one necklace and two pairs of earrings with your desired birthstone to create a fun mystery box full of surprises (value of more than $85). It’s all about the fun of not knowing what you’ll get that adds a special charm ♡

Happiness Guarantee

Easy 14-Day Returns

Free U.S Shipping

Product details
  • Your Mystery Box also doubles as a display case to hold your new, unique pieces ♡ They're packaged and ready for gift-giving, making them perfect for birthdays and other celebrations!
  • Material: 925 Sterling Silver | 18K Gold Over Brass
  • Finish: 18K Gold
  • Part of our Birthstone Collection
  • Final Sale

SKU: RR-XR015
Shipping & Care
  • Free Shipping on U.S Orders
  • Eco-friendly, ready to gift packaging
  • Carefully hand crafted and made to last ♡
  • 90-day Warranty

CM GIVES BACK

Every purchase helps protect our planet. We proudly donate 1% of our proceeds to organizations working to preserve and restore the environment through 1% for the Planet. Learn more about our Sustainability efforts.

Pairs well with
All deliveries are carbon neutral

You may also like
4.8
Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
Based on 5 reviews
5 reviews
  • Alizabeth W.
    Verified Buyer
    11/2/25
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Great gift

    It was a great gift that my sister. So loved them.

    Was this helpful?
  • Sara M.
    Verified Buyer
    7/19/25
    Rated 4 out of 5 stars
    Love everything!!!

    Three items - two pairs of earrings and a necklace! All beautiful and items I would have picked out myself. Took off one star because the one hoop doesn't close all the way. But I'll just be extra careful when I wear that pair.

    Was this helpful?
  • Patricia G.
    Verified Buyer
    5/8/25
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Extremely well made, beautiful jewelry

    There isn’t one piece of jewelry from CM that I don’t like or a gifted recipient hasn’t loved. Well made. Durable. Beautiful, classy and subtle statement pieces. I’m active with 3 active toddlers and I live in my jewelry from CM. Every piece has held up well in mud, dirt, sweat, water and sun. This is my “go to” one stop gift shop for friends, family and definitely myself!

    Was this helpful?
  • Patricia R.
    Verified Buyer
    9/10/24
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Never disappointed with anything I order

    Looks great giving it to my granddaughter for her October birthday I’m sure she will love it

    Was this helpful?
  • Preslee S.
    Verified Buyer
    8/30/24
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Birthstone Mystery Box

    I loved all the items in this!

    Was this helpful?
Show More