Skip to product information
A woman wears layered gold necklaces, adding whimsical charm to her look. The text "Mystery Jewelry" appears in a white oval at the center.
  • A woman wears layered gold necklaces, adding whimsical charm to her look. The text "Mystery Jewelry" appears in a white oval at the center.
  • A person in a gold satin dress wears four Mystery Jewelry gold and beaded bracelets, each piece adding unique flair and whimsical charm to their elegant ensemble.
  • Five Mystery Jewelry gold necklaces, each with a distinct chain style—including one accented with blue gemstones—are elegantly displayed on a curved surface, offering whimsical charm for fans of unique accessories.
  • Mystery Jewelry features a dazzling collection of gold rings, each piece crafted with whimsical charm to captivate the eye and spark curiosity.
  • Five delicate gold rings from Mystery Jewelry with small gemstones arranged on beige fabric, each piece showcasing whimsical charm and a variety of elegant, unique styles.
  • Mystery Jewelry gold and pearl earrings in assorted styles, each with whimsical charm, elegantly showcased against a cream fabric background.
  • Four pairs of Mystery Jewelry gold and opal earrings are displayed on a light surface beside a white vase, each pair showcasing the whimsical charm and uniqueness of distinctive jewelry.
  • Mystery Jewelry features three layered gold necklaces, including one with a heart-shaped pendant, displayed on a neutral background to add whimsical charm to your collection.
  • Mystery Jewelry: Two gold necklaces with green gemstone pendants displayed on a cream surface, offering whimsical charm—ideal for anyone seeking unique, intriguing accessories.
Mystery Jewelry
Ready to Ship

Mystery Jewelry

11 reviews

$14.25 $19.00
Choose Single Item or Bundle

In stock and ships next day!

Gift-Worthy: Perfect for any occasion

Celebrate the spontaneous and unexpected with our Mystery Jewelry! Each piece is a delightful surprise, offering a unique blend of whimsical charm and individual expression.

Happiness Guarantee

Easy 14-Day Returns

Free U.S Shipping

Product details
  • Material: 925 Sterling Silver | Resin | 18K Gold Over Brass | White Gold Over Brass
  • Surprise Finish: You'll receive either 18K Gold or Sterling Silver
  • Featuring a surprise pair of Earrings, a Bracelet, a Necklace, a Ring, or a Bundle Set that includes all 4 (Value of $75, Save 20%)
  • Final Sale

SKU: BB-MB004
Sizing Guide

Rings are created true to standard US sizing. For the best fit we suggest having your finger(s) sized. We offer a physical ring sizer as well! Alternatively, you may follow the steps below to find your best fit:

  1. Wrap a string around your finger where you'd like your ring to be or place the string across the inner diameter of a ring that fits you from end to end.
  2. Make sure that the string is pulled snug for the best accuracy
  3. Mark the spot where the string meets and measure with a ruler in millimeters (circumference) or measure the string's distance across the center of the ring (inner diameter)
  4. Use the circumference or inner diameter column in the chart here to find your size
Shipping & Care
  • Free Shipping on U.S Orders
  • Eco-friendly, ready to gift packaging
  • Carefully hand crafted and made to last ♡
  • 90-day Warranty

Pairs well with
All deliveries are carbon neutral

You may also like
4.8
Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
Based on 11 reviews
11 reviews
  • Melissa O.
    Verified Buyer
    11/12/25
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Super Fun!

    Really enjoyed this mystery box of high quality earrings!

    Was this helpful?
  • Sara M.
    Verified Buyer
    10/19/25
    Rated 4 out of 5 stars
    A fun surprise

    The necklace that arrived wasn't quite my style. But my daughter loves it! The surprise element was so fun! No regrets!! I'll purchase a mystery item again!

    Was this helpful?
  • Thuy C.
    Verified Buyer
    8/27/25
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    I love my mystery piece!

    I got the diamond tennis choker and absolutely love it!!!!!

    Love CM and the quality and designs. Totally me!!!

    Was this helpful?
  • Megan B.
    Verified Buyer
    7/19/25
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Pretty necklace

    I'm not into mixed metals so what I received wasn't my style, but it’s pretty and the chain is really nicely made.

    Was this helpful?
  • Rachel A.
    Verified Buyer
    7/2/25
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Super cute!

    Always happy with my mystery orders!

    Was this helpful?
Show More