Mystery Jewelry Box
Mystery Jewelry Box
Couldn't load pickup availability
- Happiness Guarantee
- Easy 14-Day Returns
- Free U.S Shipping
We will randomly handpick 4 to 5 beautiful jewelry pieces to create a fun mystery box full of surprises (value of more than $75). Your box could include anything from Necklaces and Bracelets to Rings and Earrings. It's all about the fun of not knowing what you will get!
- The Mystery Box will also include either an exclusive jewelry box or bag to hold your new, unique pieces.
- Material: High Quality Solid 925 Sterling Silver | Resin | 18K Gold Over Brass | White Gold Over Brass
- Final sale
SKU: RR-XR005
Shipping & Care
Shipping & Care
- Free Shipping on U.S Orders
- Eco-friendly, ready to gift packaging
- Carefully hand crafted and made to last ♡
- 90-day Warranty
Caitlyn Minimalist is a proud member of 1% For The Planet








- Mariana C.Verified Buyer3/28/25Rated 4 out of 5 starsGreat deal!
I was fairly new to the brand and saw a lot of pieces I liked, but I couldn't decide. When I saw that they had a mystery box, I had to try it out. 5 pieces and a jewelry box for $50 is a pretty good deal!! I ended up loving all the pieces. The only thing is I wish there could be a jewelery preference box because I got a mix (which turned out fine!) but I primarily have silver jewelry so I wish I had a choice. But other than that, I think this is a great way to try out the brand!
Was this helpful? - Sarah S.Verified Buyer3/26/25Rated 5 out of 5 starsLike a Little Treasure Chest – So Much Joy!
I took a chance on the mystery jewelry box and I’m so glad I did—it was such a fun surprise! Unboxing it felt like opening a tiny treasure chest. Each piece was beautifully curated, unique, and totally my style. You can tell there was thought put into the selection—nothing felt like filler or leftover stock.
I ended up loving every single piece, which honestly shocked me in the best way. There was a great mix of minimalist staples and a couple of more playful, standout items I wouldn’t have picked for myself—but now adore.
If you love a good surprise and discovering new jewelry gems, this box is 100% worth it. It felt like a gift to myself (and a really good one, at that).
Was this helpful? - Jacqueline M.Verified Buyer3/4/25Rated 5 out of 5 starsFun Surprise!!
The Mystery Jewelry Box didn’t disappoint! It was soo fun to unbox and see what cute pieces I received! I got a ring, a couple pairs of earrings and a necklace and while I don’t know if I would have chosen them, I absolutely love them!
Definitely worth purchasing again!!
Was this helpful? - Christa P.Verified Buyer1/24/25Rated 5 out of 5 starsLoved
I liked everything yhat came in my box and even had wrote a note that i only wear gold jewelry and they sent me only gold. Loved it
Was this helpful? - Gabriela J.Verified Buyer12/27/24Rated 5 out of 5 starsMystery Jewelry Box
I didn’t know what to expect but it was the sweetest surprise with a good selection of gold and silver pieces. I’ve received several compliments!
Was this helpful?