Best Sellers 77

Our collection of most-loved pieces, discover your new favorites for your jewelry rotation.

Cluster Baguette Birthstone Ring
Cluster Baguette Birthstone Ring
$24.75$28.50   $33$38
Best Seller
Duo Baguette Birthstone Ring
Duo Baguette Birthstone Ring
$23.62   $31.50
Best Seller
Tiny Cluster Birthstone Ring
Tiny Cluster Birthstone Ring
$23.63   $31.50
Best Seller
Sideways Initial Necklace
Sideways Initial Necklace
$27.75   $37
Best Seller
Mini Initial Tag Necklace
Mini Initial Tag Necklace
$30$45   $40$60
Best Seller
Buy Alice Initial Necklace - Gold Letter M Necklace - Simple and Elegant Design - Perfect for Daily Wear - Shop Best-Selling Jewelry at CaitlynMinimalist.com
Initial Necklace Layered 18k Gold 925 Sterling Silver Rose Gold Caitlyn Minimalist
$27.75   $37
Best Seller

You + Me: We're a Dazzling Duo 💖✨ (featuring Duo Baguette Birthstone Ring)

Athena Huggies
Athena Huggies
$19.87   $26.50
Best Seller
Eternity Birthstone Ring
Eternity Birthstone Ring
$24.75   $33
Best Seller
Thin Mini Birthstone Ring
Thin Mini Birthstone Ring
$16.12   $21.50
Best Seller
Modern Initial Birthstone Ring
Modern Initial Birthstone Ring
$19.87   $26.50
Best Seller
Callie Name Necklace in Box Chain
Callie Name Necklace in Box Chain
$31.50   $42
Best Seller
Tiny Dream Name Necklace
Tiny Dream Name Necklace
$27.75   $37
Best Seller
Tiny Summer Name Necklace
Tiny Summer Name Necklace
$27.75   $37
Best Seller
Petite Tiny Name Bracelet
Petite Tiny Name Bracelet
$27   $36
Best Seller
Mini Name Bar Bracelet
Mini Name Bar Bracelet
$31.50$46.50   $42$62
Best Seller
Dainty Tiny Name Bracelet
Dainty Tiny Name Bracelet
$27   $36
Best Seller
Custom Fingerprint Necklace
Custom Fingerprint Necklace
$34.87$42.37   $46.50$56.50
Best Seller
Editor Huggies
Editor Huggies
$15.37   $20.50
Best Seller
Emery Necklace
Emery Necklace
$23.62   $31.50
Best Seller
Linked Pendant Necklace
Linked Pendant Necklace
$23.25   $31
Best Seller
Alice Letter Name Necklace
Alice Letter Name Necklace
$27.75   $37
Best Seller
Mini Sideways Initial Necklace
Mini Sideways Initial Necklace
$23.62   $31.50
Best Seller
Vera Pave Huggies
Vera Pave Huggies
$20.25   $27
Best Seller
Mellow Name Heart Necklace
Mellow Name Heart Necklace
$38.62$53.62   $51.50$71.50
Best Seller
Dainty Tiny Multiple Name Necklace
Dainty Tiny Multiple Name Necklace
$34.87   $46.50
Best Seller
Summer Name Necklace
Summer Name Necklace
$27.75   $37
Best Seller
Baguette Birthstone Bracelet
Baguette Birthstone Bracelet
$23.63   $31.50
Best Seller
Marquise Birthstone & Pearl Ring
Marquise Birthstone & Pearl Ring
$23.62   $31.50
Best Seller
Tiny Heart Birthstone Ring
Tiny Heart Birthstone Ring
$19.87   $26.50
Best Seller
Ribbed Flower Tag Necklace
Ribbed Flower Tag Necklace
$35.25$42.75   $47$57
Best Seller
Thea Twisted Huggies
Thea Twisted Huggies
$17.62   $23.50
Best Seller
Dainty Mama Necklace
Dainty Mama Necklace
$27.75   $37
Best Seller
Summer Name Necklace in Box Chain
Summer Name Necklace in Box Chain
$31.50   $42
Best Seller
Mellow Name Necklace
Mellow Name Necklace
$27.75   $37
Best Seller
Minimal Name Necklace
Minimal Name Necklace
$27.75   $37
Best Seller
Satellite Necklace
Satellite Necklace
$23.25   $31
Best Seller
Handwriting Band
Handwriting Band
$23.62$31.12   $31.50$41.50
Best Seller
Large Sideways Initial Necklace
Large Sideways Initial Necklace
$23.62   $31.50
Best Seller
Ann Skinny Name Ring
Ann Skinny Name Ring
$19.87$27.37   $26.50$36.50
Best Seller
Tiny Birthstone Ring
Tiny Birthstone Ring
$16.12   $21.50
Best Seller
Dainty Tag Name Necklace
Dainty Tag Name Necklace
$30$37.50   $40$50
Best Seller
Mini Lily Studs
Mini Lily Studs
$17.62   $23.50
Best Seller
Amanda Link Earrings
Amanda Link Earrings
$19.50   $26
Best Seller
Interlocking Family Necklace
Interlocking Family Necklace
$31.50$39   $42$52
Best Seller
Pave Chain Ear Cuffs
Pave Chain Ear Cuffs
$19.87   $26.50
Best Seller
Handwriting Necklace
Handwriting Necklace
$29.62   $39.50
Best Seller
Handwriting Bracelet
Handwriting Bracelet
$27.75   $37
Best Seller
Initial Birthstone Necklace
Initial Birthstone Necklace
$27.75   $37
Best Seller
Diamond Station Necklace
Diamond Station Necklace
$29.25   $39
Best Seller
Letter Heart Necklace
Letter Heart Necklace
$23.62   $31.50
Best Seller
Tiny Grace Name Necklace
Tiny Grace Name Necklace
$27.75   $37
Best Seller
Dangling Birth Flower Earrings
Dangling Birth Flower Earrings
$21$28.50   $28$38
Best Seller
Baguette Birthstone Ring
Baguette Birthstone Ring
$19.87   $26.50
Best Seller
Brinley Pearl Choker
Brinley Pearl Choker
$31.50   $42
Best Seller
Dome Hoops
Dome Hoops
$19.87   $26.50
Best Seller
Baguette Diamond Studs
Baguette Diamond Studs
$19.87   $26.50
Best Seller
Mini Name Bar Necklace
Mini Name Bar Necklace
$33$44.25   $44$59
Best Seller
Minimalist Stacking Ring Set
Minimalist Stacking Ring Set
$23.62   $31.50
Best Seller
Nina Link Earrings
Nina Link Earrings
$19.50   $26
Best Seller
Handwriting Bar Necklace
Handwriting Bar Necklace
$31.50$39   $42$52
Best Seller
Ann Thin Message Ring
Ann Thin Message Ring
$21.75$29.50   $29$39
Best Seller
Paperclip Toggle Necklace
Paperclip Toggle Necklace
$27.75   $37
Best Seller
Elena Diamond Studs
Elena Diamond Studs
$17.62   $23.50
Best Seller
Tiny Multiple Name Bracelet
Tiny Multiple Name Bracelet
$31.50$39   $42$52
Best Seller
Duo Marquise Birthstone Ring
Duo Marquise Birthstone Ring
$23.62   $31.50
Best Seller
Duo Marquise Baguette Ring
Duo Marquise Baguette Ring
$23.62   $31.50
Best Seller
Mini Initial Paperclip Necklace
Mini Initial Paperclip Necklace
$30$45   $40$60
Best Seller
Custom Pet Keychain
Custom Pet Keychain
$31.50$39   $42$52
Best Seller
Elegant Pave Name Necklace
Elegant Pave Name Necklace
$35.25   $47
Best Seller