Best Sellers 199

Our collection of most-loved pieces, discover your new favorites for your jewelry rotation.

Shop All

Best Sellers

New Arrivals

Gift Guide

Filter +
Mini Sideways Initial Necklace
Mini Sideways Initial Necklace
Mini Sideways Initial Necklace
$23.62   $31.50
New Arrivals
Mini Initial Tag Necklace
Mini Initial Tag Necklace
Mini Initial Tag Necklace
$30 – $45   $40 – $60
Editor's Pick
Mini Initial Paperclip Necklace
Mini Initial Paperclip Necklace
Mini Initial Paperclip Necklace
$30 – $45   $40 – $60
New Arrivals
Duo Baguette Birthstone Ring
Duo Baguette Birthstone Ring
Duo Baguette Birthstone Ring
$23.62   $31.50
Editor's Pick
Tiny Heart Birthstone Ring
Tiny Heart Birthstone Ring
Tiny Heart Birthstone Ring
$19.87   $26.50
New Arrivals
Baguette Birthstone Ring
Baguette Birthstone Ring
Baguette Birthstone Ring
$19.87   $26.50
Editor's Pick

Personalize your stack with a subtle pop of you ✨ (featuring best-seller Ophelia Birthstone Necklace)

Tiny Summer Name Necklace
Tiny Summer Name Necklace
Tiny Summer Name Necklace
$27.75   $37
Editor's Pick
Mellow Name Heart Necklace
Mellow Name Heart Necklace
Mellow Name Heart Necklace
$38.62 – $53.62   $51.50 – $71.50
New Arrivals
Mini Name Bar Necklace
Mini Name Bar Necklace
Mini Name Bar Necklace
$31.50 – $46.50   $42 – $62
Editor's Pick
Pastel Opal Inlay Huggies
Pastel Opal Inlay Huggies
Pastel Opal Inlay Huggies
$23.62   $31.50
Ready to Ship
Opal Inlay Huggies
Opal Inlay Huggies
Opal Inlay Huggies
$23.62   $31.50
Ready to Ship
Bold Opal Inlay Huggies
Bold Opal Inlay Huggies
Bold Opal Inlay Huggies
$23.62   $31.50
Ready to Ship
Dainty Mama Necklace
Dainty Mama Necklace
Dainty Mama Necklace
$27.75   $37
Ready to Ship
Custom Fingerprint Necklace
Custom Fingerprint Necklace
Custom Fingerprint Necklace
$34.87 – $42.37   $46.50 – $56.50
New Arrivals
Pave Interlocking Necklace
Pave Interlocking Necklace
Pave Interlocking Necklace
$29.62   $39.50
Ready to Ship
Tiny Multiple Name Bracelet
Tiny Multiple Name Bracelet
Tiny Multiple Name Bracelet
$31.50 – $39   $42 – $52
New Arrivals
Mini Name Bar Bracelet
Mini Name Bar Bracelet
Mini Name Bar Bracelet
$31.50 – $46.50   $42 – $62
Editor's Pick
Petite Tiny Multiple Name Bracelet
Petite Tiny Multiple Name Bracelet
Petite Tiny Multiple Name Bracelet
$31.50 – $39   $42 – $52
New Arrivals
Classic Diamond Tennis Bracelet
Classic Diamond Tennis Bracelet
Classic Diamond Tennis Bracelet
$31.12   $41.50
Waitlist Available
Diamond Tennis Choker Necklace
Diamond Tennis Choker Necklace
Diamond Tennis Choker Necklace
$34.87   $46.50
Waitlist Available
Snake Chain Bracelet
Snake Chain Bracelet
Snake Chain Bracelet
$27.75   $37
Ready to Ship
Genevieve Birthstone Huggies
Genevieve Birthstone Huggies
Genevieve Birthstone Huggies
$21.75   $29
Ready to Ship
Birthstone Ear Jackets
Birthstone Ear Jackets
Birthstone Ear Jackets
$19.87   $26.50
Ready to Ship
Baguette Birthstone Huggies
Baguette Birthstone Huggies
Baguette Birthstone Huggies
$19.87   $26.50
Ready to Ship
Agate Emerald Ring
Agate Emerald Ring
Agate Emerald Ring
$26.25   $35
Ready to Ship
Art Deco Diamond Ring
Art Deco Diamond Ring
Art Deco Diamond Ring
$29.25 – $29.95   $39
Ready to Ship
Harley Emerald Ring
Harley Emerald Ring
Harley Emerald Ring
$26.25   $35
Ready to Ship
Alice Letter Name Necklace
Alice Letter Name Necklace
Alice Letter Name Necklace
$27.75   $37
Editor's Pick
Callie Name Necklace in Box Chain
Callie Name Necklace in Box Chain
Callie Name Necklace in Box Chain
$31.50   $42
Personalized
Summer Name Necklace in Box Chain
Summer Name Necklace in Box Chain
Summer Name Necklace in Box Chain
$31.50   $42
Editor's Pick
Bridget Pearl Huggies
Bridget Pearl Huggies
Bridget Pearl Huggies
$23.62   $31.50
Ready to Ship
Knot Pearl Drop Earrings
Knot Pearl Drop Earrings
Knot Pearl Drop Earrings
$19.50   $26
Ready to Ship
Isha Pearl Drop Earrings
Isha Pearl Drop Earrings
Isha Pearl Drop Earrings
$21.75   $29
Ready to Ship
Ribbed Flower Tag Necklace
Ribbed Flower Tag Necklace
Ribbed Flower Tag Necklace
$35.25 – $42.75   $47 – $57
New Arrivals
Birthstone Diamond Pendant Necklace
Birthstone Diamond Pendant Necklace
Birthstone Diamond Pendant Necklace
$27.75   $37
New Arrivals
Ophelia Birthstone Necklace
Ophelia Birthstone Necklace
Ophelia Birthstone Necklace
$26.25   $35
Ready to Ship
Petite Tiny Name Bracelet
Petite Tiny Name Bracelet
Petite Tiny Name Bracelet
$27   $36
Editor's Pick
Pave Link Chain Bracelet
Pave Link Chain Bracelet
Pave Link Chain Bracelet
$29.62   $39.50
Waitlist Available
Dainty Tiny Name Bracelet
Dainty Tiny Name Bracelet
Dainty Tiny Name Bracelet
$27   $36
Personalized
Sideways Initial Necklace
Sideways Initial Necklace
Sideways Initial Necklace
$27.75   $37
Editor's Pick
Initial Heart Locket Necklace
Initial Heart Locket Necklace
Initial Heart Locket Necklace
$31.50   $42
Ready to Ship
Dainty Initial Necklace
Dainty Initial Necklace
Dainty Initial Necklace
$27.75   $37
Ready to Ship
Editor II Huggies
Editor II Huggies
Editor II Huggies
$16.12   $21.50
Ready to Ship
Bold Ribbed Hoops
Bold Ribbed Hoops
Bold Ribbed Hoops
$19.88   $26.50
Ready to Ship
Thea Twisted Huggies
Thea Twisted Huggies
Thea Twisted Huggies
$17.62   $23.50
Ready to Ship
Emery Necklace
Emery Necklace
Emery Necklace
$23.62   $31.50
Ready to Ship
Rae Diamond Necklace
Rae Diamond Necklace
Rae Diamond Necklace
$23.62   $31.50
Ready to Ship
Emery Birthstone Necklace
Emery Birthstone Necklace
Emery Birthstone Necklace
$23.62   $31.50
Ready to Ship
Margot Pearl Hoops
Margot Pearl Hoops
Margot Pearl Hoops
$19.50   $26
Ready to Ship
Rebecca Pearl Drop Earrings
Rebecca Pearl Drop Earrings
Rebecca Pearl Drop Earrings
$23.25   $31
Ready to Ship
Baroque Pearl Earrings
Baroque Pearl Earrings
Baroque Pearl Earrings
$19.50   $26
Ready to Ship
Thin Mini Birthstone Ring
Thin Mini Birthstone Ring
Thin Mini Birthstone Ring
$16.12   $21.50
Editor's Pick
Modern Initial Birthstone Ring
Modern Initial Birthstone Ring
Modern Initial Birthstone Ring
$19.87   $26.50
Editor's Pick
Cluster Baguette Birthstone Ring
Cluster Baguette Birthstone Ring
Cluster Baguette Birthstone Ring
$24.75 – $28.50   $33 – $38
New Arrivals
Editor Huggie Earrings
Editor Huggie Earrings
Editor Huggie Earrings
$15.37 – $19.87   $20.50 – $26.50
Ready to Ship
Editor Huggies
Editor Huggies
Editor Huggies
$15.37   $20.50
Ready to Ship
Amelia Duo Huggies
Amelia Duo Huggies
Amelia Duo Huggies
$27   $36
Ready to Ship
Initial Pendant Necklace
Initial Pendant Necklace
Initial Pendant Necklace
$29.62   $39.50
Ready to Ship
Buy Alice Initial Necklace - Gold Letter M Necklace - Simple and Elegant Design - Perfect for Daily Wear - Shop Best-Selling Jewelry at CaitlynMinimalist.com
Initial Necklace Layered 18k Gold 925 Sterling Silver Rose Gold Caitlyn Minimalist
Alice Dainty Initial Necklace
$27.75   $37
Editor's Pick
Letter Heart Necklace
Letter Heart Necklace
Letter Heart Necklace
$23.62   $31.50
Personalized
Flower Pearl Drop Earrings
Flower Pearl Drop Earrings
Flower Pearl Drop Earrings
$21.75   $29
Ready to Ship
Molly Pearl Huggies
Molly Pearl Huggies
Molly Pearl Huggies
$19.50   $26
Ready to Ship
Ivy Flower Earrings
Ivy Flower Earrings
Ivy Flower Earrings
$17.62 – $24.75   $23.50 – $33
Ready to Ship
Diamond Stacking Ring Set
Diamond Stacking Ring Set
Diamond Stacking Ring Set
$31.50   $42
Waitlist Available
Thin Stacking Rings Set
Thin Stacking Rings Set
Thin Stacking Rings Set
$23.62   $31.50
Ready to Ship
Skinny Stacking Rings Set
Skinny Stacking Rings Set
Skinny Stacking Rings Set
$23.62   $31.50
Ready to Ship
Laura Starburst Duo Necklace
Laura Starburst Duo Necklace
Laura Starburst Duo Necklace
$34.87   $46.50
Ready to Ship
Linked Pendant Necklace
Linked Pendant Necklace
Linked Pendant Necklace
$23.25   $31
Ready to Ship
Marquise Diamond Necklace
Marquise Diamond Necklace
Marquise Diamond Necklace
$29.62   $39.50
Ready to Ship
Vera Pave Huggies
Vera Pave Huggies
Vera Pave Huggies
$20.25   $27
Ready to Ship
Diamond Drop Huggies
Diamond Drop Huggies
Diamond Drop Huggies
$24.75   $33
Ready to Ship
Athena Huggies
Athena Huggies
Athena Huggies
$19.87   $26.50
Ready to Ship
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

Shop Must-Have Earrings

Shop Name & Initials