Best Sellers ²⁰⁰

Our collection of most-loved pieces, discover your new favorites for your jewelry rotation.

Shop All

Best Sellers

New Arrivals

Gift Guide

Filter +

Product Type

Finish

Availability

Duo Baguette Birthstone Ring

$31.50

Best Seller

Cluster Baguette Birthstone Ring

$33 – $38

Best Seller

Duo Marquise Baguette Ring

$31.50

Best Seller

Dainty Knot Pearl Earrings

$26

Best Seller

Knot Pearl Drop Earrings

$26

Best Seller

Isha Pearl Drop Earrings

$29

Best Seller

Symbolizing love and connection, wear the legacy of love 🤍✨

Initial Pendant Necklace

$39.50

Best Seller

Buy Alice Initial Necklace - Gold Letter M Necklace - Simple and Elegant Design - Perfect for Daily Wear - Shop Best-Selling Jewelry at CaitlynMinimalist.com

Initial Necklace Layered 18k Gold 925 Sterling Silver Rose Gold Caitlyn Minimalist

Alice Dainty Initial Necklace

$37

Best Seller

Mini Initial Tag Necklace

$40 – $60

Best Seller

Eternity Birthstone Ring

$33

Best Seller

Duo Marquise Birthstone Ring

$31.50

Best Seller

Eternity Tennis Birthstone Ring

$33

Best Seller

Athena Huggies

$26.50

Best Seller

Pave Cartilage Mini Huggies

$21.50

Best Seller

Amelia Duo Huggies

$36

Best Seller

Initial Heart Locket Necklace

$42

Best Seller

Custom Fingerprint Necklace

$46.50 – $56.50

Best Seller

Endless Love Locket Necklaces

$42

Best Seller

Ivy Flower Studs

$23.50

Best Seller

Ivy Flower Earrings

$23.50 – $33

Best Seller

Ivy Flower Hoops

$33

Best Seller

Duo Vertical Baguette Ring

$31.50

Best Seller

Marquise Birthstone & Pearl Ring

$31.50

Best Seller

Tiny Cluster Birthstone Ring

$31.50

Best Seller

Diamond Flatback Studs

$23.50 – $26.50

Best Seller

Coco Pave Huggies

$26

Best Seller

Booker Diamond Studs

$20.50

Best Seller

Heart Birthstone Necklace

$37 – $42

Best Seller

Toi et Moi Birthstone Ring

$31.50

Best Seller

Toi et Moi Birthstone Necklace

$35

Best Seller

Mini Hammered Hoops

$26 – $29

Best Seller

Mini Bold Hoops

$26.50 – $31.50

Best Seller

Editor Huggie Earrings

$20.50 – $26.50

Best Seller

Mini Name Bar Bracelet

$42 – $62

Best Seller

Dainty Tiny Name Bracelet

$36

Best Seller

Baguette Birthstone Bracelet

$31.50

Best Seller

Callie Name Necklace in Box Chain

$42

Best Seller

Tiny Dream Name Necklace

$37

Best Seller

Tiny Summer Name Necklace

$37

Best Seller

Thin Stacking Rings Set

$31.50

Best Seller

Crystal Stacking Ring Set

$42

Best Seller

Diamond Stacking Ring Set

$42

Best Seller

Triple Diamond Studs Set

$33 – $59.40

Best Seller

Diamond Drop Huggies

$33

Best Seller

Art Deco Huggies

$26.50

Best Seller

Dainty Tiny Multiple Name Necklace

$46.50

Best Seller

Mellow Name Heart Necklace

$51.50 – $71.50

Best Seller

Elegant Pave Name Necklace

$47

Best Seller

Classic Diamond Tennis Bracelet

$41.50

Best Seller

Essential Bracelet Chains

$29 – $37

Best Seller

Must-Have Bracelet Chains

$29 – $41.50

Best Seller

Modern Initial Birthstone Ring

$26.50

Best Seller

Thin Mini Birthstone Ring

$21.50

Best Seller

Art Deco Birthstone Ring

$35

Best Seller

Sapphire Flower Earrings Set

$35 – $63

Best Seller

Opal Inlay Huggies

$31.50

Best Seller

Birthstone Ear Jackets

$26.50

Best Seller

Essential Necklace Chains

$31 – $49

Best Seller

Dainty Diamond Necklace

$31.50

Best Seller

Emery Birthstone Necklace

$31.50

Best Seller

Editor II Huggies

$21.50

Best Seller

Editor Huggies

$20.50

Best Seller

Paris Oval Hoops

$26

Best Seller

Sideways Initial Necklace

$37

Best Seller

Alice Letter Name Necklace

$37

Best Seller

Dainty Initial Necklace

$37

Best Seller

Bold Pearl Drop Earrings

$31.50

Best Seller

Dangling Pearl Drop Earrings

$26

Best Seller

Dainty Pearl Drop Huggies

$28

Best Seller

Vintage Pave Pearl Ring

$35

Best Seller

Pearl Diamond Stacking Rings

$31 – $42

Best Seller

Tiny Heart Birthstone Ring

$26.50

Best Seller

Best Sellers 200

Best Sellers ²⁰⁰